[SOLVED] URL in Create team membership in Server (Bun) sdk

Based on this documentation:
https://appwrite.io/docs/references/cloud/server-nodejs/teams#createMembership

It indicates or labeled the url is an optional parameter. However in the sdk have this
createMembership(teamId: string, roles: string[], url: string, email?: string, userId?: string, phone?: string, name?: string): Promise<Models.Membership>;

As you can see the urlparameter is not optional. I am creating a membership through Server sdk. I think that no need to pass a url parameter? since it automatically add the member right?

await teams.createMembership($id, ["owner"], "", undefined, ownerRef);

as you can see I just left empty string in url passing values. But the error message said:

Error creating team: Invalid url param: URL host must be one of: localhost, cloud.appwrite.io

I believe the URL is optional in a mobile app - the SDK will automatically handle redirecting back to the app.

I think this is consider as a bug on server sdk?

No, why?

url parameter in server sdk is required😩

the documentation said that the url parameter should be an optional

It's optional for mobile. If you're not on mobile, you'll need to set a redirect URL - how would Appwrite know where to send the user, otherwise?

As I said earlier, The documentation tells that in server sdk it automatically added the user in team

other one

as you can see the URL does not have required label so I think the Server sdk should also do the optional parameter

Url, become useless if the server side will auto added the member. Hence, there is no need to pass a url

Wait, I see what you're saying, sorry. I just checked the SDK, and as far as I can tell, url is an optional parameter in the server SDKs - https://github.com/appwrite/sdk-for-node/blob/3e4e6ce7b1227be7ba7938b188a37df63cc24e4c/index.d.ts#L4120

why I am getting a required parameter

ohh I see I forgot to update the appwrite version, I thought was the bun template using the latest version of appwrite

thanks for the help

If your issue has been solved, you can close this post by adding “[SOLVED]” to the beginning of the title

[SOLVED] URL in Create team membership in Server (Bun) sdk