New Users not created on OAuth2 Login

When I try to login with google oauth2, the new user that is to be created is added as an identity to the previous user instead of being created as different user.
The emails are different and in no way related but still it adds the new email as identity of the previous ones

its possible that if a user is alread logged-in when the OAuth was performed, it might be linked as an identity. Can you try logging out the current user by deleting the session and then trying the OAuth?